Category Archives: New Information

The Historical Meaning of “Natural Born Citizen” —
Part 5: The Supreme Court Speaks

[To start at the very beginning, click here.]  “Four Supreme Court Cases” In the fall of 2009, a blog called “The Post & Email” ran an article which claimed that four US Supreme Court cases had defined the term “natural … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 61 Comments

US State Department Policy Relevant to Natural Born Citizenship in the 1880s and 1890s

 As we’ve seen in the 1856 Presidential election campaign of John Charles Fremont, there never seems to have been any problem in recognizing that persons born in the United States to non-citizen parents were natural born citizens. By the 1880s, … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 10 Comments

The Historical Meaning of “Natural Born Citizen” —
Part 4: The Civil War and Beyond (1862-1872)

[To start at the very beginning, click here.]  In this part, we’ll turn our attention to the developments in citizenship law after the 1857 Dred Scott decision. The first significant development we’ll note is an 1862 Opinion on Citizenship written … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 2 Comments

The Historical Meaning of “Natural Born Citizen” —
Part 3: Antebellum America [1825–1860s]

[To start at the very beginning, click here.]  Having examined the meaning of “natural born citizen” during the lifetime of the Founders, let’s look at what it meant between that time and the US Civil War. The founding of the … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 4 Comments

Evidence Found that American Common Law Defined Whether a Child Born on US Soil of Non-Citizen Parents Was a Natural Born Citizen! (Lynch v Clarke, 1844)

[Note: This post began as a portion of Part 3 of this blog’s final article. It has been split out to make a post of its own.]  Previously at this blog, we’ve looked at Mario Apuzzo’s claim that American common … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 26 Comments

The Historical Meaning of “Natural Born Citizen” —
Part 2: In the Early United States [1787–1825]

[To start at the very beginning, click here.]  In Part 1 of this article, we looked at the available historical clues up to the writing of our Constitution, for the meaning of “natural born citizen.” In this part, we’ll see … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 44 Comments

The Historical Meaning of “Natural Born Citizen” —
Part 1: Before the Constitution [up to 1787]

“Your… argument is absurd given that historically a “natural born Citizen” had only one definition, i.e., a child born in the country to citizen parents. There never has been any other definition. So your attempt to go looking for one … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 68 Comments

The Latest Birther Idiocy — Article from Mara Zebest Claims that Savannah Guthrie “Proves She’s Complicit” in Obama Birth Certificate “Forgery”

I hope the birther readers of my blog will forgive me for stating the obvious when I use the term “idiocy” — but frankly, after more than a year, I am finally about running out of patience for the ludicrous … Continue reading

Posted in New Information, Stuff Birthers Believe | 23 Comments

John Jay, Alexander Hamilton, and the Mystery of the “Natural Born Citizen” Letter

Famous Letter from Jay to Washington Proposed a Constitutional “Natural Born Citizen” Clause In the summer of 1787, leaders from across America were gathered in Philadelphia in a convention that would create a new Constitution for the fledgling United States. … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 134 Comments

Natural Law, Calvin’s Case and the Meaning of “Natural Born Citizen”

For the past 3 years, a few people have been pushing the idea that the Constitutional term “natural born citizen” comes from “natural law” or the “law of nature” — and that by the law of nature, “it takes two … Continue reading

Posted in Conclusions, Natural Born Citizen, New Information | 9 Comments